• Home
  • About
  • Service
    • Mortgage & Lienholders
  • Client Portal
  • Locations
    • Appleton
    • Kimberly
  • Personal Insurance
    • Auto Insurance
    • Home Insurance
    • Watercraft Insurance
    • ATVs, Campers, Cycles, etc.
    • Life Insurance
    • Pet Insurance
    • Self Defense Liability
  • Commercial Insurance
    • Business Insurance
    • Contractors Insurance
    • Trucking Insurance
  • Reviews
  • Blog
  • Contact us

Thiel Insurance Group, LLC - Appleton & Kimberly


Get a Quote!
Appleton: 920-739-6241
Kimberly: 920-788-4131

June 4, 2026

What is Umbrella Insurance?

Imagine you are driving home on a rainy Tuesday evening. You glance down for a split second, traffic suddenly stops, and you rear-end the car in front of you. It triggers a multi-car accident. Two people are seriously injured, requiring extensive surgeries and months of missed work.

Within weeks, the medical bills and legal demands total $750,000.

You feel awful, but you breathe a sigh of relief because you have “good auto insurance.” But then you look at your policy’s declaration page and notice your bodily injury liability limit caps out at $300,000.

Who pays the remaining $450,000?

Without a safety net, that money comes directly out of your retirement accounts, your home equity, and your future wages. This is exactly where Umbrella Insurance steps in.

What is Umbrella Insurance?

Think of your standard auto and homeowners insurance policies like primary shields. They protect you up to a certain dollar limit. An umbrella policy is an extra layer of liability protection that sits on top of those shields.

Umbrella Insurance visual

When a catastrophic accident occurs, and your primary auto or home liability limits are exhausted, the umbrella policy steps in to cover the rest, up to your chosen limit (usually starting at $1 million).

Furthermore, it doesn’t just pay the damages; it also covers your legal defense fees, which can easily rack up tens of thousands of dollars before a case even goes to trial.

The Biggest Myth: “I’m Not a Millionaire, So I Don’t Need It”

Many people assume umbrella insurance is an exclusive luxury item for the ultra-wealthy. In reality, it is designed to protect what you accumulate over your lifetime.

A judge or jury doesn’t check your current bank account balance before awarding a settlement. If you are found liable for a major accident, your future wages can be garnished for years to come. If you own a home, have a retirement fund, or have a steady income, you have assets worth protecting.

The Everyday Risk Factors

You don’t have to be reckless to face a massive lawsuit. Common, everyday situations that drastically increase your liability exposure include:

  • Having a Teenage Driver: Statistically, teens are involved in more accidents, and as the parent, you are financially responsible.
  • Owning a Dog: Even the friendliest dogs can bite if startled. A single dog bite claim can easily spiral into six figures for medical and psychological trauma.
  • Having a Pool or Trampoline: Your backyard becomes an “attractive nuisance” in legal terms. If a neighborhood kid gets hurt on your property, the liability falls squarely on you.
  • Hosting Social Gatherings: If a guest leaves your holiday party or summer BBQ intoxicated and causes an accident on the way home, you could face a social host liability lawsuit.

The Best Part? It’s Incredibly Affordable

Because umbrella insurance only kicks in after a major primary policy limit is breached, the risk to the insurance company is relatively low. Because of that, the cost to you is surprisingly small.

The Cost Breakdown: A typical $1 million umbrella policy costs between $150 and $300 per year (about $15 to $25 per month). Adding a second million or higher maybe an option for additional premium.

For the price of a couple of streaming subscriptions, you can entirely eliminate the risk of a freak accident wiping out your life savings.

How to Get Covered

To qualify for an umbrella policy, insurance companies will require you to carry certain minimum underlying limits on your auto and home policies (usually $250,000/$500,000 for auto bodily injury and $300,000 for home liability).

The easiest and most cost-effective way to set this up is to bundle your auto, home, and umbrella policies with a single independent agency. This ensures there is no coverage gaps between your primary shields and your umbrella safety net.

Are you exposed? Take five minutes to pull up your current insurance policies and look at your liability limits. If you’re ready for a quick, zero-pressure coverage checkup to see how an umbrella policy fits into your financial plan, call or email our office today.

Author

  • Boyd Thiel
    Boyd Thiel

    Boyd Thiel is an agent at Thiel Insurance Group. He can be reached at 920-788-4131.

    View all posts

Article by Boyd Thiel / Uncategorized

Insurance can be confusing at times and everyone's needs are different. If you have questions regarding coverage, pricing, or anything else related to insurance, send us an email or give us a call.

If you'd like to get a free, no-obligation quote, all you have to do is ask!

Contact Thiel Today!

Get a Quote!
Refer a Friend!
Thiel Insurance Group, LLC5.0
Based on 1014 reviews
See all reviews
review us on
Milagros C.
1 day ago
J V.
6 days ago
Jarret was great to work with! He was very knowledgeable and responded to all of my questions almost immediately. He also explained everything thoughroly and in easy to understand terms. Start to finish my new policy was set up in less than 2 days and I'm now saving over $1000 per year!
Jeff B.
1 week ago
Hunter and Theil Group helped us with a tricky cross country move and new property purchase. They were efficient, quick, and had great communication. I would highly recommend them.
Jonah K.
2 weeks ago
Hunter has been so helpful with me and very patient with me on the phone helped save me 3500$ a year on my policy and added a vehicle. Will be recommending to all my friends
Lola S.
2 weeks ago
Enjoy working with Thiel Insurance Group. We are confident the products presented are in our best interest. All of our questions are always answered promptly and completely. Thiel Insurance Group protects us very well.
Lexi M.
2 weeks ago
We have had an outstanding experience working with Thiel Insurance Group for over 10 years! They take the time, year after year, to understand our needs and find us the best home and auto insurance coverage at a great value. What has stood out most recently is how much they care about making sure our growing family is protected. They patiently walked us through our life insurance options and helped us choose the best policy to protect our new baby. The entire process was stress-free, thorough, and personalized. We truly felt like they had our family’s best interests at heart. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, trustworthy, and responsive independent insurance agent!
ppc4 P.
2 weeks ago
Used Thiel Insurance for Home & Auto. Hunter was very on top of his stuff and was able to answer every question immediately on the phone call. Definitely recommend.
Collin P.
2 weeks ago
Super professional and real personalities to talk to. Unlike the huge agencies that treat you like a number.
Tessa J.
2 weeks ago
Thiel insurance group has been my insurance agent for the last several years for my business insurance, personal auto and home insurance, and life insurance policies. They are always responsive, friendly, and always have my best interest in mind. highly recommend!!
Becky M.
2 weeks ago
Thiel Insurance Group has been amazing to work with! Chloe's attention to detail, quick response time, and ongoing support exemplify outstanding customer service. Thanks, Chloe!
Mik Elaine N.
2 weeks ago
We just changed insurance carriers for our Home, Umbrella and Auto policies, due to the prior company's overly high renewal rates. Kim Plovanich did a wonderful job for us by quoting and installing new policies with a new carrier, saving us a LOT of money in the coming year! Kim was very responsive, thorough and upfront about what was needed and when! Thank you so much Kim, and thank you Thiel insurance for great service!! God bless you all!!
Lisa P.
3 weeks ago
Hunter made it extremely easy for us to switch insurance carriers. The process was extremely easy and he was very responsive to our questions throughout the entire process. Thank you, Hunter!
Mike K.
1 month ago
Working with Amanda R was a pleasant, informative, thorough and speedy process. If you feel your insurance portfolio needs an update, Thiel is an excellent choice; Amanda R is one of the best guides I've found across any line of business. My previous carrier neglected to pay attention to my family's needs during their agent transition. The deadline for key policies was 7 and 30 days, and my schedule was touch and go. Yet, Amanda R researched and provided enough of an overview to allow this to happen with 2 days to spare! Thank you so much Thiel Insurance-Appleton and Amanda R.
Nick M.
1 month ago
Hunter was very thorough and helpful when helping me establish my business insurance, and also got me a cheaper rate on renters and auto. I felt well taken care of, and would recommend working with Thiel Insurance.
Tyler Z.
1 month ago
I had an amazing experience with Hunter, he answered all my questions and communicated everything extremely well. I highly recommend using them for any insurance needs - I will most definitely continue to use their services!
Joseph E.
1 month ago
Very knowledgeable with questions asked. Went above and beyond to get the best rate possible for Commercial Trucking Insurance.
Lonzo D.
1 month ago
Thanks to Hunter & Lisa and Angie for being outstanding and for following up in every way to meet my Auto Insurance needs especially during these un-easy times, I will be referring both friends and family....
Carrie H.
2 months ago
Great to be back in Wisconsin, Hunter is awesome as our new insurance agent! Great service and very pleasant!
Mischelle H.
2 months ago
Friendly
Cameron R.
2 months ago
Hunter is great to work with and knows his stuff. He was able to add more coverage and get my wife and I a better deal on our insurance. Highly recommend working with Hunter!
Casey W.
2 months ago
Holy cow, they saved me a ton of money. Professional service and savings!
Olivia P.
2 months ago
Hunter was fantastic and super helpful! He took the time to explain things thoroughly and was open to any and all questions. Would recommend to anyone!
Jack G.
2 months ago
Hunter was an absolute delight to work with - has great knowledge and wisdom to help us find the best deal!
Sam L.
2 months ago
Chloe was extremely helpful when opening my new car insurance. Create with communication.
sarah T.
2 months ago
Great coverage options with a full detailed explanation of policies and coverage!

AAA Membership!

AAA Membership

Proud Member of…

Pet Insurance?

That's right. Health insurance for your pet can save you thousands.

Syra

Get a Quote!

Thiel Insurance Group, LLC

An independent insurance agency serving the Fox Valley since 1960. Thiel Insurance Group, LLC BBB Business Review

Appleton Location

Thiel Insurance Group, LLC
620 N. Richmond St
Appleton, WI 54911
Phone: 920-739-6241
Fax: 920-739-3591

Kimberly Location

Thiel Insurance Group, LLC
122 W. Kimberly Ave
Kimberly, WI 54136
Phone: 920-788-4131 
Toll-Free: 866-788-4131 
Fax: 920-788-6795

Hours

Mon – Thur:
8:00 – 5:00
Friday 8:00 – 3:00
Saturday and Sunday Closed
Most Anytime by Appointment

Follow Us

Facebook Icon LinkeIn Icon YouTube Icon

Copyright © 2026 - Thiel Insurance Group, LLC - Legal - Privacy Policy - Sitemap