• Home
  • About
  • Service
  • Client Portal
  • Locations
    • Appleton
    • Kimberly
  • Insurance
    • Auto Insurance
    • Home Insurance
    • Watercraft Insurance
    • ATVs, Campers, Cycles, etc.
    • Business Insurance
    • Life Insurance
    • Pet Insurance
  • Reviews
  • Blog
  • Contact us

Thiel Insurance Group, LLC - Appleton & Kimberly


Get a Quote!
Appleton: 920-739-6241
Kimberly: 920-788-4131

January 6, 2026

Why You Should Review Your Insurance Every Year

Annual Insurance Review

Life tends to move fast. In a single year, you might buy a new car, finish a basement, or even get married. While these moments are exciting, they often change what you need from your insurance. Most people tend to buy a policy and then forget about it. However, setting aside time for an annual review with your agent can be a smart way to make sure your protection keeps up with your life.

An annual review is basically a check-up for your personal insurance. It is a chance to look at your Homeowners, Auto, and other policies to see if they still make sense for you. Because prices and life situations change, what worked last year might not be the best fit today. Taking a little time to talk with your agent can help you spot things you might have otherwise missed. Many people find that their lives change more than they realize over 12 months, and their insurance should change along with it.

Changes to Your Home and Property

Your home is likely one of your biggest investments. Because of this, keeping your Homeowners insurance up to date is very important. Many people do not realize that the cost to rebuild a house can change over time. If you have made updates to your property, those changes should likely be reflected in your policy so you are not left with a gap in coverage.

Home Remodels and Improvements

If you have spent money to make your home better, your old policy might not reflect the new value. Generally speaking, if you have done any of the following, you may want to mention it during your review:

  • Kitchen or Bathroom Upgrades: New counters, custom cabinets, or high-end appliances can increase the cost to replace your home.
  • Adding a Deck or Patio: Outdoor living spaces are common additions that change your property value and how you use your yard.
  • Finishing a Basement: This adds a lot of livable square footage that should likely be accounted for in your total coverage limit.
  • New Roof: In some cases, a new roof might even help you find a better rate because it makes the home safer from leaks and weather damage.

When you finish a project, it is easy to focus on the new paint or the shiny appliances. However, it is just as important to think about the financial protection for those items. If a kitchen fire were to happen due to a covered loss, you would want your policy to reflect the actual cost of the new materials you just installed.

The Rising Cost of Building Materials

Even if you have not touched a hammer, the cost of wood, shingles, and labor often goes up due to inflation. If your policy limit stays the same for years, it might not be enough to cover the cost of rebuilding after a covered loss. This is why many people choose to have an annual conversation with their agent. An experienced agent can help you look at current local building costs to see if your Homeowners limits should be adjusted to stay current with the market.

Keeping Your Auto Insurance Up to Date

Auto insurance is something most people rarely think about. During a review, you can look at who is driving, how the cars are being used, and if your limits still protect your current lifestyle.

Changes in Your Daily Commute

The way you use your car can change your insurance needs. For example, if you started working from home, you are likely driving fewer miles than you used to. Depending on the company you are insured with, driving fewer annual miles could result in a lower premium. On the other hand, if you started a new job with a long commute, you may want to make sure your Auto policy reflects that change so there are no surprises later.

New Drivers in the House

If you have a teenager who just got their permit or license, you will generally need to add them to your Auto policy. While this usually increases the cost, your agent can help you find ways to manage those expenses. Many companies offer discounts for students who get good grades or take safety courses. Talking about these options during a review can help you plan your budget for the coming year.

The Age of Your Vehicle

As a car gets older, its market value usually drops. For an old car, you might decide that some types of coverage, like collision, is no longer worth the cost. This is a personal choice that depends on your savings and your comfort with risk. A review is the best time to weigh those options and decide if the cost of the coverage makes sense given the value of the car.

Important Milestones and Liability

Insurance is not just about physical items like a car or a house. It is also about protecting your financial future. Liability insurance helps protect your savings and your future income if you are found responsible for an accident. As you gain more assets or reach new life milestones, your need for liability protection generally grows.

  1. Marriage or Divorce: Changing your legal status often means combining policies or splitting them up.
  2. Starting a Small Business: If you started a Business out of your home, your standard Homeowners policy might not cover your equipment or your liability. You should likely talk to an advocate about whether you need a separate Business policy or an endorsement to your current one.
  3. Buying High-Value Items: If you bought an expensive engagement ring, a rare coin collection, or fine art, these items may have limited coverage under a standard policy. You might need to add a special “rider” to ensure they are protected in the event of a covered loss.

Understanding Your Deductibles and Costs

One of the most common reasons to have an annual review is to look at your budget. Most people want to save money, and there are several ways to look at costs without losing the protection you need. An experienced agent can help you find a balance that feels right for your bank account.

The Balance Between Deductibles and Premiums

A deductible is the amount you pay out of pocket before the insurance company steps in to help. Generally speaking, if you choose a higher deductible, your monthly premium will be lower. During your review, you can ask yourself if you have enough savings to cover a higher deductible if an accident happens. If you have more money in the bank now than you did last year, raising your deductible might be a way to lower your monthly bills.

Looking for New Discounts

Insurance companies change their discount programs from time to time. You might now qualify for a discount that did not exist when you first signed up. Common discounts that an advocate might look for include:

  • Security Systems: Installing a burglar alarm or smoke detectors that call the fire department can often lead to savings.
  • Paperless Billing: Choosing to get your statements through email instead of the mail is a simple way to save a few dollars.
  • Paying in Full: Paying for six months or a year at once instead of month-to-month can sometimes reduce the total cost.
  • Safe Driver Programs: Some companies offer lower rates if you use a plug-in device or a phone app that tracks safe driving habits.

How to Prepare for Your Review

A review does not have to be long or difficult. It is usually just a simple conversation over the phone or in person. To make the most of it, you might want to have a few things ready before you speak with your experienced advocate:

  • A list of any big purchases you made in the last year, like jewelry or electronics.
  • An idea of how many miles you are driving each year on each of your vehicles.
  • A list of any safety upgrades you made to your home, such as a new security camera system.
  • Any questions you have about what your policy actually does and what it does not do.

Remember, we are an advocate for you. We are there to listen to your concerns and help you understand the fine print. You should feel free to ask questions if something sounds confusing. There are no bad questions when it comes to protecting your family and your property.

Final Thoughts on Annual Reviews

An annual insurance review is a simple way to stay organized and prepared. It helps ensure that your Homeowners and Auto policies are doing what you expect them to do. While no policy covers every possible situation, staying informed is the best way to avoid surprises.

By talking with an experienced advocate once a year, you can make sure your coverage keeps up with your life. Whether you are saving money with new discounts or increasing your limits because of a home remodel, a quick check-up is usually worth the time. It gives you the chance to breathe easy, knowing that you have looked at your options and made the best choices for your situation.

Documents To Gather for Your Annual Insurance Review

Getting ready for a talk with your agent is a great way to make sure your meeting is productive. While you do not need to have every single receipt, having a few key items ready can help your listener understand your current life. Generally speaking, being prepared allows you to focus on finding the right protection for your Homeowners and Auto needs.

The following list includes items that are often helpful to have on hand during your review.

Your Current Insurance Policies

It is usually a good idea to have your current “declarations pages” nearby. These are the pages that show your coverage limits and what you are paying now.

  • Auto Policy Details: This shows your current deductibles and which cars are on the plan.
  • Homeowners Policy Details: This includes the estimated cost to rebuild your home and your liability limits.
  • Other Policies: If you have an Umbrella or Life policy, having those details can help your advocate see the big picture.

Home and Property Records

If you have made changes to where you live, these documents can help ensure your Homeowners coverage is accurate.

  • Home Improvement Receipts: If you finished a basement or remodeled a kitchen, have a rough idea of what you spent.
  • Safety Upgrade Proof: If you installed a new security system or smoke alarms, keep the certificates or receipts. In some cases, these can lead to new discounts.
  • New Roof Documentation: Having the date your new roof was finished is very helpful for your Homeowners record.

Vehicle and Driving Information

Because your daily habits can change, keeping your Auto information current is a smart move.

  • Current Mileage: It is helpful to check the odometer on each car so you can give an accurate estimate of your annual miles.
  • Commute Changes: If you moved or changed jobs, knowing the new distance to your office is important.
  • New Driver Information: If a child just got a permit, have their date of birth and license number ready.

Special Items and Personal Assets

Standard policies often have limits on certain types of property. To protect these due to a covered loss, you may need extra documentation.

  1. High-Value Receipts: If you bought a new piece of jewelry, expensive electronics, or fine art, keep the sales receipts.
  2. Professional Appraisals: For very rare or old items, a recent appraisal can help set the right value for your coverage.
  3. Business Information: If you started a small business from home, have a list of any equipment you use for work.

Questions and Future Plans

Finally, take a moment to write down any life changes you expect in the coming year. Generally speaking, knowing your plans helps your agent prepare for your future.

  • Upcoming Moves: Are you planning to buy a new home or rent an apartment?
  • Big Purchases: Do you plan on buying a new car or a boat soon?
  • General Concerns: Write down any parts of your policy that seem confusing so you can ask for a simple explanation.

Having these items ready helps you and your friendly advocate work together to find the best fit for your budget and your family.

Feel free to call or email us if you have any questions or would like to schedule a review.

Author

  • Boyd Thiel
    Boyd Thiel

    Boyd Thiel is an agent at Thiel Insurance Group. He can be reached at 920-788-4131.

    View all posts

Article by Boyd Thiel / Personal Insurance

Insurance can be confusing at times and everyone's needs are different. If you have questions regarding coverage, pricing, or anything else related to insurance, send us an email or give us a call.

If you'd like to get a free, no-obligation quote, all you have to do is ask!

Contact Thiel Today!

Get a Quote!
Refer a Friend!
Thiel Insurance Group, LLC5.0
Based on 898 reviews
See all reviews
review us on
Mary S.
18 hours ago
Hunter was great and saved me $600 a year in my insurance!
Jay M.
23 hours ago
Great customer service. Always willing to help where they can!
Charlie J.
2 days ago
Hunter and Team did a phenomenal job onboarding me in. Quick, seamless, and a great experience overall. Glad I reached out to them!
Eric J.
3 days ago
We recently moved and needed to find mortgage insurance and they made the process easy also bundling our car insurance. Very happy with the pricing and the experience we had with Thiel insurance.
Grant B.
3 days ago
Hunter went above and beyond to earn our business. We were having trouble getting coverage for our home with multiple other agents due to heating with an outdoor wood boiler, but Hunter was able to find us coverage and make switching a breeze!
Brooke G.
3 days ago
Hunter is super personable and always makes sure to put the needs of his customers first! Highly recommend going through Thiel Insurance.
Courtney T.
3 days ago
Chad W.
1 week ago
Thiel insurance is the only place to go for your insurance needs! Hunter took care of us with all off our policies with our best interest in mind. He found great pricing for us with reputable companies, overall great experience!!
Jackie P.
2 weeks ago
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I can’t say enough great things about Thiel’s Insurance Group! We worked with Hunter, and he was incredibly knowledgeable, responsive, and truly cared about finding the best coverage for our needs. He made the process of securing trucking insurance and housing insurance smooth and stress-free, explaining everything clearly and making sure we felt confident in our coverage. It’s rare to find an insurance group that’s this reliable and easy to work with. Highly recommend Thiel’s Insurance Group — and especially Hunter — to anyone looking for trustworthy and professional service!
Jacob S.
2 weeks ago
Switched my commercial trucking from Secura to Acuity and my personal policies from other carrier using Thiel insurance group. Very fast and knowledgeable. 10/10
Tanner B.
2 weeks ago
Excellent company to do business with. Hunter is super friendly and knowledgeable!
Nikki B.
2 weeks ago
Joe K.
4 weeks ago
Super fast response to my online form submittal. Hunter did a great job showing me the with and without options to cost compare, he was kind and helpful, and I got comparison shopping without spam like the online "aggregators." Feels much better to not be locked into single, national insurer. Really liked that we could hop on a Teams call saving me the drive.
Carol K.
4 weeks ago
Working with the Thiel Insurance group and been a dream. Fast replies, clear communication and they didn't push, just educated. I highly recommend!
Mark R.
1 month ago
Cindy provided us with excellent service. .She was thoughtful, knowledgeable,and courteous in all our conversations concerning providing auto and renters insurance.Cindy represents your group very well, indeed !
Matt M.
1 month ago
Hunter got me a quote within an hour and was very competitively priced. Made the process smooth and easy. Highly recommend!
Connor D.
1 month ago
Hunter was able to help us understand what was available for insurance and obtain a more comprehensive plan to cover our home and auto
Kyra C.
1 month ago
Danny J.
1 month ago
Working with Hunter was a great experience. Very nice person and made insurance easy. Got us a great deal and was quick with it. Telling everybody I know to go through Thiel Insurance.
Jaclyn
1 month ago
I would 100% recommend Thiel Insurance Group to anyone! Hunter was super helpful and easy to work with!

He sent over prices quickly and guided me to pick the best option for me. He fought to get me the best price and let me know what all of my options were.

Thank you, Hunter, for such a smooth and seamless process!
Matthew G.
2 months ago
Hunter helped us out with a great business insurance policy. Took Less than a week to get everything sorted out. Great customer service, highly recommend.
Bryce C.
2 months ago
Came here for my business insurance and Hunter made the process so easy for someone who didn’t know much about insurance to understand and the rates were lower than I expected to pay. Now my fiancé and I are getting married so we came in to see if we could save some more money and streamline all of our other policy’s, home, 2 auto policy’s, snowmobile, boat, atv, and again, very simple, we have 5x better coverage than we did previously and we’re paying significantly less. 10/10 experience!
Callie T.
2 months ago
Hunter was great to work with! He helped my husband and I find the best rates and policies to fit our needs. Excellent experience overall.
Gregory D.
2 months ago
Chris B.
2 months ago
Very helpful with explaining and deciding proper coverages for all of our insurance needs
BETHANY N.
2 months ago
It was so easy to work with Hunter at Thiel Insurance Group. He was very responsive and helpful. He handled so many questions with patience and a wealth of knowledge. He gave me several options as we looked at a complicated Auto policy while also answering questions about Homeowners and Umbrella policies.
arul J.
2 months ago
Cindy was awesome to work with. Would Recommend Cindy at Thiel, and if everyone is like Cindy, Thiel Insurance Group is the place to goto in the area.
Ximena M.
2 months ago
Thank you Hunter for helping with my new insurance policy. Thank you for caring as much as you did!
Kelly D.
2 months ago
Hunter was fantastic to deal with on my startup Commercial Trucking Insurance! Highly recommended!
Eric T.
2 months ago
Thiel insurance did a great job of reviewing my insurance needs and getting me the proper insurance. Great job!
Ivy W.
3 months ago
Outstanding service from Hunter, he truly cares about the clients. He took the time to explain all my options and made sure I had the best policy for my needs. He was also quick to respond, knowledgeable, and a pleasure to work with. Excellent service, I definitely recommend!.
Ivy K.
3 months ago
recommends
Outstanding service from Hunter, he truly cares about the clients. He took the time to explain all my options and made sure I had the best policy for my needs. He was also quick to respond, knowledgeable, and a pleasure to work with. Excellent service, I definitely recommend!.
Hannah H.
3 months ago
Hunter was great to work with! He found us multiple options at great prices. Appreciated his timely and friendly communication so much.
Ron/Dee W.
3 months ago
Fiesta Acres Condominium Phase B Owners Association lost their insurance because the company stop offering condo insurance in 2025, so as Secretary of the Board found the opportunity to work with Cindy Casey at Thiel Insurance Agency. The Board found her pleasant to work with, more than willing to go beyond expectations, and helpful in finding us a solution. We are pleased with the condo insurance policy she was able to offer, the attentiveness, concern, and empathy to us as clients, the successful results, and the follow-up service. We are grateful with having done business with Cindy because of her all-around service and would recommend Thiel Insurance Agency and Cindy Casey as a team to consider doing business with.
Justin G.
3 months ago
Worked with Hunter to get auto and home insurance quotes. His communication was great and he was quick to answer any questions I had. I was able to get a better rate for the same coverage. Definitely will be back my future insurance needs!
Arianna L.
3 months ago
Boyd and Jarret made swapping insurances a breeze. Wonderful to work with and incredibly helpful. Thank you Boyd and Jarret for everything!
Brian M.
3 months ago
Very easy to work with and provided a very quick turnaround time for my personal insurance quotes.
Sam N.
3 months ago
Worked with Jarret (& Boyd) to get Auto, Renters, and Life insurance. They were both awesome! Super responsive and answered all the questions I had! Highly recommend!
Carrie C.
3 months ago
Hunter was wonderful at helping me find a car insurance policy that cost less than half of my former policy!! The office staff was very friendly as well!!
Russ N.
3 months ago
We cant thank Hunter and the team at Thiel Insurance Group enough for helping facilitate all of our insurance needs. From all of our personal lines to our business and more, The process was seamless and the knowledge and customer service is First rate! We wouldn't hesitate to recommend them to anyone for their insurance needs.
Scott J.
3 months ago
Fantastic for small business insurance, I couldn’t find anything online that could work for me but their actual humans did thanks so much!!
Trumann S.
4 months ago
I worked with Hunter he’s been great. My insurance dropped me because of the kind of siding I had not only did they pick me up from my Insurance, but they bundled my Home and Auto I’m getting much better rates with much more coverage. And he’s been very patient with me throughout the process.
Melissa K.
4 months ago
They found me exactly what I was looking for in a policy!
Alex D.
4 months ago
Hunter and his team are professional, friendly and I couldn't say enough good things about this business, 10/10 highly recommend !!
Joshua W.
4 months ago
Hunter was great to work with.
Thomas L.
5 months ago
Jimmy H.
5 months ago
Hunter was really easy to work with and saved us a bunch on our Insurance. Highly recommend Thiel Insurance Group.
Tanner S.
5 months ago
Hunter Thiel was great to work with, he saved me hundreds of dollars a month for car insurance. Quick and reliable. Thanks Hunter!!
Aiden
5 months ago
The person that helped helped a lot with helping me get lower rates
Jeff L.
5 months ago
Great experience with Hunter at Thiel insurance!! Helped me save over $1,2000 a year!
Heather D.
6 months ago
Hunter was wonderful to work with. Personable and thorough. We were on a time crunch and he made it happen. So grateful for his expertise. AND he saved us hundreds.
Heather W.
6 months ago
Hunter was very helpful with any questions that I had before purchasing my policies! He was always available & very prompt in getting back to me. I would definitely recommend!
Hanna S.
6 months ago
I had a great experience working with Brenda from Thiel Insurance. It was my first time obtaining homeowners insurance, and she was wonderful at explaining everything involved in the process and helping me find insurance that fit my needs and my budget. All while being a personable, easy going person to talk with.
Kevin G.
6 months ago
Great service. Saved me a lot. Thanks Hunter
Carly H.
6 months ago
Hunter & the Team were great to work with! Very responsive!
Mitchell Van L.
6 months ago
recommends
There is a reason they are so highly rated, they earned it, they deserve it! Best customer service, great pricing for my business, I even referred some of my other business owner friends, who also found them to be the best choice, best price, best customer service all around. Hunter is our agent and I message him, and boom, Answered! No hesitation, no apologies, just great service!
Sarah S.
6 months ago
Hunter was great to work with! He provided quotes quickly and made the transition to Thiel Insurance seamless!
Chris M.
6 months ago
Hunter and the Thiel Insurance Group were a pleasure to work with. Hunter searched for our best options, took the time to review the policies in complete detail, and helped us onboard in a seamless manner. We're looking forward to working with them for a long time to come.
Denise M.
6 months ago
Hunter is very knowledgeable, so happy to make switch and save money on auto and home insurance. Highly recommend.
Tiffany Scott S.
7 months ago
recommends
Hunter is very knowledgeable and responsive.
Cyndi A.
9 months ago
When I decided to switch insurance companies after 45 years, I asked friends who they recommended and I was given the name Acuity as a carrier. I hadn't heard of them but found Thiel Insurance Group in Appleton. I called and got an appointment set up right away with Kim. We met in person, which I wanted. I didn't want to sign up online, I wanted to meet and talk to an actual person. She answered all my questions, and I had quite a few since I had the same company for so long. I appreciated the time she took to help me and I felt comfortable that she understood me and would be there if I had questions or needed help in the future. I am glad I made the move, they make you feel right a home and appreciated!
Pedro A.
9 months ago
Best customer service ever!!! Super fast and easy communication!! Huge thanks to Hunter Thiel on the Appleton location.
Barbara C.
9 months ago
Kelly L.
9 months ago
I submitted our info for a quote and Hunter was on it quickly and efficiently. He was able to save us quite a bit of money while also substantially increasing our coverage. Really glad I found him- he was a pleasure to work with and went above and beyond to help submit all the necessary info!
Craig S.
10 months ago
We just switched our insurance from a carrier we had been with for over 25 years. We started 'shopping' because they were no longer providing Home Insurance in Wisconsin, but Jarret did an outstanding job finding us better Auto/Home/Umbrella coverage at a significant savings! We highly recommend Thiel Insurance!
Dan C.
10 months ago
Just switched our insurance over from a company we had been at for over 40 years. Insurance has gotten a bit crazy lately and the team at Thiel Insurance did a great job working through our options and finding the coverage we needed at very competitive pricing. Thank you!!!
Boyd D.
10 months ago
Jarrett was very easy to work with, responded very quickly and found us the best and cheapest options
Tom
10 months ago
Christine T.
11 months ago
Boyd is as friendly and knowledgeable as they come . Thank you Thiel Insurance for covering all of insurance needs from homeowners to life insurance and everything in between.
Robert K.
1 year ago
Great, been a policy holder for house and autos and rental policies for years. They're very easy to work with and thorough with all their work. Coundn't be happier.
Holly B.
1 year ago
Stacey did a wonderful job explaining the options for home insurance. She also found much better rates for car insurance. They really do treat their clients like family, and the dog is the sweetest!
dan H.
1 year ago
Boyd and Jarret were very responsive to our questions while we were researching our options. They were able to find us insurance policies that met our needs. Fast responses and very thorough! Highly recommend!
Jeffrey M.
1 year ago
recommends
We have had great service from Boyd and his group for years. We would recommend them for all your insurance needs.
Mitch Van O.
1 year ago
Rob L.
1 year ago
Fast response to an RFQ to potentially change insurance companies. Hunter recommended to stay with my current insurance for the best value. Fast and thorough response. If I were to change insurance, would definitely consider Thiel.
Gregory B.
1 year ago
Hunter did a great job replacing our insurance policies covering two homes, two cars, multiple recreational vehicles, and boats in addition to an umbrella liability. He was able to add some coverages we needed while still reducing our overall premium. I highly recommend working with him.
Scott S.
1 year ago
Julie H.
1 year ago
Boyd did a wonderful job explaining the different options in life insurance.
M. S.
1 year ago
Hunter was very professional and worked with me to move my auto and home insurance to a more affordable plan as well as adding an umbrella policy. He answered all my questions and promptly replied to my e-mails and phone calls.
Jacquelyn S.
2 years ago
Family agency with extensive insurance knowledge. Highly recommended!!
Al G.
2 years ago
We are very pleased to have joined Thiel Insurance. They have made us feel very glad e made the change.
Pat S.
2 years ago
Lisa very friendly was a
Big Help changing agency
Tim R.
2 years ago
Boyd was an immense help getting our policy in place after 10 years with a different agency. He took the time to answer our questions and make us feel comfortable with the change. Very impressed with the quick responsiveness and local knowledge.
Kyna S.
2 years ago
recommends
Worked with Hunter and Stacey to quickly get an auto and home policy after having an issue come up with our previous home owners policy. Stacey was quick to send me information and forms to get the ball rolling and Hunter was quick to get us a quote and get everything in place!! Both were friendly and the process was so easy! Thank you Stacey and Hunter!
Tom S.
2 years ago
Fabulous experience the Thiel Insurance Group. Boyd did a great job of explaining everything and answering my questions. He is very responsive but never pushy. Everyone I've met there is a joy to work with.
Jeanne Z.
2 years ago
I am very grateful for all the help I have received from Boyd and the office staff. I never hesitate to ask for advice about questions I have.
Lori A Van L.
2 years ago
recommends
I have had to reach out, after hours, and spoke with Hunter Thiel. HE IS AMAZING! I appreciate being in an unfamiliar situation, calling and receiving much needed info. He quickly and kindly helped me resolve the situation. #thielinsurancelifer
Nathan H.
2 years ago
I have been with Thiel for over 17 years and have never once had a single complaint. When you call, there is always someone in the office ready to assist you. We have had Carrie be our primary Agent for some time now and she makes everything so simple to understand as well as so easy to attain we couldn't be happier with her!
Michael W.
2 years ago
Very friendly and knowledgeable
Tammy B.
2 years ago
Hunter was excellent to work with and answered all of our questions, highly recommend!
Isaac W.
2 years ago
Phylliss J.
2 years ago
Have a great experience with Thiel Insurance every time I go there. Thank you all.
Elijah W.
2 years ago
Hunter is a great communicator and truly cares for his costumers! He has saved me money over and over again on my policies ! Fully recommend even for a quote !
Russ O.
2 years ago
Boyd and Carrie not only handled my insurance needs, but also brought to my attention the deficits of my current insurance coverage. Which has since been addressed.

I appreciate their prompt and professional service.
Kazem H.
2 years ago
Amazing amazing service! He helped me out go over my Arizona quotes and was extremely knowledgeable and fair. Felt complete trust with him
Aimee C.
2 years ago
Thanks for helping me with my car insurance
Patrick R.
2 years ago
recommends
Stacy was very knowledgeable, helpful, and friendly - I honestly didn't think the process could be that easy! I came away feeling like I was a person, not just a customer 😊😊
Hailey P.
2 years ago
Hunter was great to work with! He was super helpful with answering all of my questions and also super fast, which I appreciated as I needed insurance for my business in a short time frame. I will be back for all of my insurance needs!
Ben R.
2 years ago
recommends
Hunter gets things done! I put him on the job a week after three other insurance companies, and he still got me to the signature line first and ended up being the lowest premium.
LeRoy D.
2 years ago
Our ins premiums were raised quite a bit from a national co so after 15 years with them it was time to see what what available. We'd rather have someone locally to work with so i found Theil ins on google. We're glad we did because they found us a company that gave much more coverage with less premium's and they were informative, fun, and painless to work with. Highly recomend them.
Ben B.
2 years ago
recommends
Started with my boat insurance, and I was so happy with the service and price that I moved all my policy's over. Thanks for always being there when my family has questions!
Haley F.
2 years ago
Fantastic customer service and great overall communication from employees. I love that they stay in touch with me and make sure that I am getting the best rate possible. Jarret has been great to talk to and he gets things done quick, which I appreciate. We bundle home and auto insurance and I would recommend them to anyone looking to switch for a better rate.
Ethan N.
3 years ago
Just got a quote from Hunter, who was extremely kind and professional. He explained to me what each policy covered in detail and made switching insurance super easy. Hunter was able to offer the same coverage for WAY cheaper than my current insurance provider (Allstate). Very happy customer of Thiel Insurance Group!
Stacie S.
3 years ago
Great experience with helping me pick the coverages I needed and going over my policies. Very friendly and easy to talk to and work with. Felt the were looking out for my best interest.
Kristin W.
3 years ago
We recently met with Boyd and he did a tremendous job of assisting us in searching for a thorough comparison of policies for auto and home insurance! He took the time to meet with us in person, discuss our options and answer all of our questions. We appreciate the care and personal attention he gave to us during this process and we would highly recommend Thiel Insurance Group LLC to anyone looking for a great local representative.
Ben J.
3 years ago
Thiel has been great and mainly because of their agents like Kim and Lisa. They are rockstars there and have helped me out tremendously. Extremely helpful. Extremely knowledgeable and you can definitely tell they love helping people. I haven't got to work with others there but I imagine they all have the same attitude. Kim, if you read this thank you so much for all you have done for me over the years. Thank you!
Michael L.
3 years ago
Extremely responsive and thorough. Regardless of the question or obstacle, my family has been able to get quick feedback, detailed explanations and communication that is clear and concise throughout the past decade. I have thrown a few curve balls their way in adjusting and redesigning my coverage and they have met everything with poise and professionalism. Strongly recommend.
steve S.
3 years ago
The best of the best
Brad W.
3 years ago
Jarret is great to work with. I have been with Thiel Insurance for over 20 years. The renewal came through this year and increased significantly, Jarret noticed it and took care of looking for another policy that would work for us. I recommend Thiel Insurance Group LLC to everyone.
Jen Guyette H.
3 years ago
recommends
I wish I could give 10 stars!! I have to give a HUGE Thank You to Hunter at Thiel Insurance Group, LLC. We insured our camper through them roughly 6 months ago. Out of the blue we get a call from Hunter saying he found better coverage that's more affordable. He added that he did his homework and the company is great to work with. In the 30 years that I've had to pay for insurance, We've never had an agent call me unprovoked with better rates and coverage. Thank you again Hunter. We appreciate you and your attention to detail and for always looking out for your customers! 😃
Joyce B.
3 years ago
recommends
Love working with Pat, she has really helped us with a new quote and helped us save mone, but still have great coverag. Thanks Pat
David T.
3 years ago
recommends
Responsive! Good Knowledgeable people who remember you.
Greener Grass I.
3 years ago
recommends
We began referring our tenants to Hunter out of the Appleton office when he was able to show us that our renters were paying too much for renters insurance through other agencies. He is getting them better coverage (which we like) at a better price (which they like)!
Dean S.
4 years ago
recommends
I've been working with Patty at the Appleton office for many years, and her customer service is second to none. She saved my family >$1,000 this year! I highly recommend the Thiel Insurance Team!

Thanks - Dean
JoAnne D.
4 years ago
recommends
I just switched over to Badger Plus insurance, through Thiel insurance.

Leah, the agent, was awesome. she was very detailed on informing me what would work best for me. She didn't hesitate on any questions I had.

I'd recommend Leah to everyone.

JoAnne DeBriyn
Sue D.
4 years ago
recommends
CHECK THEM OUT-WE GOT WAY MORE COVERAGE AND FOR LESS MONEY via car/rental than the company we have been with since 1980. Great people to work and patient/understanding.
Christy G.
4 years ago
recommends
Kim did an AMAZING job! I got an apartment on a Tuesday and was set up with new policies by the time I moved that Friday! From start to finish, Kim had me set up in about a day and a half. Thanks Kim!!!
Emily B.
4 years ago
recommends
Great Team and very Efficient!!
Allie W.
4 years ago
recommends
My family has gotten insurance through Thiel for generations. I didn't know why, until I received the same kind, respectful, and prompt service. Hunter and Patty have both helped me get the right insurance, for a great value. They're reliable, and always looking for a better value for me.
Jeffrey S.
4 years ago
recommends
Always great wo work with. Any time you need to make changes they go over everything to insure you are up to date and covered
Carla K.
4 years ago
recommends
Have been with Thiel Insurance Group for over 6 years and always have had excellent service! Just called recently about my currant car insurance with questions and payments and had quick answers and changes for my benefit! I even changed my mind and recalled, and they were so cheerful and helpful! Highly recommend them for your insurance needs!
Nathan T.
5 years ago
recommends
Hunter by far is one of the best people to work with, everything is straight forward and easy! Highly recommend for simplicity and peace of mind.

AAA Membership!

AAA Membership

Proud Member of…

Pet Insurance?

That's right. Health insurance for your pet can save you thousands.

Syra

Get a Quote!

Thiel Insurance Group, LLC

An independent insurance agency serving the Fox Valley since 1960. Thiel Insurance Group, LLC BBB Business Review

Appleton Location

Thiel Insurance Group, LLC
620 N. Richmond St
Appleton, WI 54911
Phone: 920-739-6241
Fax: 920-739-3591

Kimberly Location

Thiel Insurance Group, LLC
122 W. Kimberly Ave
Kimberly, WI 54136
Phone: 920-788-4131 
Toll-Free: 866-788-4131 
Fax: 920-788-6795

Hours

Mon – Thur:
8:00 – 5:00
Friday 8:00 – 3:00
Saturday and Sunday Closed
Most Anytime by Appointment

Follow Us

Facebook Icon LinkeIn Icon YouTube Icon

Copyright © 2026 - Thiel Insurance Group, LLC - Legal - Privacy Policy - Sitemap