Appleton

As you may have already read on the About page of our site, Thiel Insurance Group has been serving the Fox Valley for more than 50-years. With offices in Appleton and Kimberly, our agency serves communities throughout the Fox Valley including: Neenah, Menasha, Combined Locks, Grand Chute, Greenville, and Kaukauna.

In addition to being a business in the Fox Valley, we live here as well. Thiel Insurance Group employees are active supporters of many schools, churches, and groups.

Address

620 N Richmond St
Appleton, WI 54911

Phone

Phone: 920-739-6241
Text: 920-739-6241
Fax: 920-739-3591

Email

General Inquiry: sthiel@thielinsurancegroup.com

Hours of Operation

Monday – Friday: 8:30 – 5:00
Saturday and Sunday Closed
Most Anytime by Appointment

Map

Get Directions

From

Add Waypoint

For

show options hide options

Avoid Tolls Avoid Highways Avoid Ferries

Excellent

Thiel Insurance Group, LLC

Based on 739 reviews

See all reviews

review us on

Carrie C.

Hunter was wonderful at helping me find a car insurance policy that cost less than half of my former policy!! The office staff was very friendly as well!!

Russ N.

We cant thank Hunter and the team at Thiel Insurance Group enough for helping facilitate all of our insurance needs. From all of our personal lines to our business and more, The process was seamless and the knowledge and customer service is First rate! We wouldn't hesitate to recommend them to anyone for their insurance needs.

Trumann S.

I worked with Hunter he’s been great. My insurance dropped me because of the kind of siding I had not only did they pick me up from my Insurance, but they bundled my Home and Auto I’m getting much better rates with much more coverage. And he’s been very patient with me throughout the process.

Melissa K.

They found me exactly what I was looking for in a policy!

Alex D.

Hunter and his team are professional, friendly and I couldn't say enough good things about this business, 10/10 highly recommend !!

Joshua W.

Hunter was great to work with.

Thomas L.

Tanner S.

Hunter Thiel was great to work with, he saved me hundreds of dollars a month for car insurance. Quick and reliable. Thanks Hunter!!

Aiden

The person that helped helped a lot with helping me get lower rates

Jeff L.

Great experience with Hunter at Thiel insurance!! Helped me save over $1,2000 a year!

Heather D.

Hunter was wonderful to work with. Personable and thorough. We were on a time crunch and he made it happen. So grateful for his expertise. AND he saved us hundreds.

Heather W.

Hunter was very helpful with any questions that I had before purchasing my policies! He was always available & very prompt in getting back to me. I would definitely recommend!

Hanna S.

I had a great experience working with Brenda from Thiel Insurance. It was my first time obtaining homeowners insurance, and she was wonderful at explaining everything involved in the process and helping me find insurance that fit my needs and my budget. All while being a personable, easy going person to talk with.

Kevin G.

Great service. Saved me a lot. Thanks Hunter

Carly H.

Hunter & the Team were great to work with! Very responsive!

Mitchell Van L.

There is a reason they are so highly rated, they earned it, they deserve it! Best customer service, great pricing for my business, I even referred some of my other business owner friends, who also found them to be the best choice, best price, best customer service all around. Hunter is our agent and I message him, and boom, Answered! No hesitation, no apologies, just great service!

Mitchell Van L.

Sarah S.

Hunter was great to work with! He provided quotes quickly and made the transition to Thiel Insurance seamless!

Chris M.

Hunter and the Thiel Insurance Group were a pleasure to work with. Hunter searched for our best options, took the time to review the policies in complete detail, and helped us onboard in a seamless manner. We're looking forward to working with them for a long time to come.

Denise M.

Hunter is very knowledgeable, so happy to make switch and save money on auto and home insurance. Highly recommend.

Scott M.

Tiffany S.

Hunter is amazing. Easy to work with, knowledgeable, and professional.

Emma B.

Helped me save over $2700 a year on my auto and first home!

Tiffany Scott S.

Hunter is very knowledgeable and responsive.

Dan D.

As a local Realtor, I’ve had the opportunity to work with many insurance professionals over the years — but Hunter Thiel with Thiel Insurance Group truly stands out. When it came time to insure our short-term rental Airbnb property, Hunter made the entire process incredibly smooth and stress-free. His knowledge of the industry and ability to tailor the right coverage for our unique situation gave us total peace of mind — and at a price that made sense.

What really sets Hunter apart is his communication. He’s consistently responsive, always willing to jump on a quick call, and never makes you feel like a number. With Thiel Insurance Group, you’re not getting passed around a call center — you’re working directly with Hunter every time. That personal touch and accountability are rare in today’s world, and it means everything when you’re navigating important decisions like insurance.

Hunter brings the perfect mix of youthful energy and seasoned wisdom. He’s professional, proactive, and a true asset to have in your corner. For anyone looking for a reliable, trustworthy insurance partner, Hunter is a no-brainer. Thanks again, Hunter, for being such a key part of our team — we’re grateful for everything you do.

SHAWN H.

Hunter at Thiel Insurance Group is so nice and extremely helpful. I would recommend this company to anyone due to their superior customer service, knowledge, quick response and competitive prices!

Aline B.

The team handled my transition to a new insurance seamlessly and with great professionalism. Everything went smoothly—highly recommend!

HRN

Imagine my surprise when I learned that Thiel had selected the absolute maximum, including every single bell and whistle, while claiming I was getting the best deal available. They hadn't executed changes I requested, and had made other changes without my authorization. I'll be handing my plan myself from here on out. Over a decade with them to learn they'd been taking advantage of me for years.

Elijia K.

Hunter was very easy to work with and handled every question I had (and there were quite a few) with patience and finesse. Very happy with how transparent he was!

Bobbi H.

Thank you to Hunter for helping me add my son as a new driver and saving me money!!

Evan O.

Hunter was able to save me nearly 2 Thousand dollars a year on my insurance and provided superior coverage. The process was smooth and they helped me terminate my old policies to further streamline the process. no nonsense. quick response time. I would absolutely recommend Thiel Insurance Group.

Erin G.

Hunter helped me get auto and home insurance! It was my first time getting insurance and he took the time to go through everything and explain what he recommended. I highly recommend!!

Doug D.

Hunter was great throughout the quoting process. He quickly responded to email requests and was accommodating to appointment times. He made the process easy and answered all my questions. I hope to continue to work with him for my future insurance needs.

Travis K.

Hunter did a great job finding the right policy for our needs.

Lindsay H.

Jane A.

Fast, professional and friendly service! Highly recommend!

John G.

We could not be happier with our choice to work with Thiel Insurance Group for our auto and home owner's insurance! Not only were they able to get us better coverage for a better price than we had with our previous insurance carrier, they found the lack of proper coverage in our prior home owner's policy could have cost us thousands of extra dollars had we had to file a claim. The team at Thiel Insurance Group is absolutely fantastic in regards to following up on questions or when policy changes need to be made. Let's face it, we're all just one severe storm or car accident away from needing to file an insurance claim. Knowing we have the team at Thiel Insurance Group not only for support, but as a partner in these times of need gives us a "peace of mind" that is priceless. Thanks again Thiel Insurance Group for the great products you represent, and the absolutely great team of people you employ, you are truly appreciated!

Megan K.

Incredibly efficient enrollment. Hunter was so helpful, my new insurance plan is more affordable. Overall, very content with the transition, much appreciated!

Joshua F.

Beth H.

I needed to change all of my insurance policies and find a new trustworthy agency. The Thiel Agency in Appleton came highly recommended from a friend I can't say enough good things about my experience. Lisa was so kind and helpful before I stepped in the door. She set up a time for me to meet with Tyler. This was my first time shopping for policies on my own. Tyler truly looked out for my best interest while putting together policies that were tailored to my needs Tyler was not only knowledgeable, but efficient, answered all of my questions, and explained things I didn't understand. He was easy to reach and followed through with everything. I'm grateful to have had the chance to work with Tyler at The Thiel Agency in Appleton. Thanks for looking out for me!!

Russ H.

Had a very nice experience with Hunter! Great guy! Saved us money on what we were currently paying for auto and home insurance! Thank you Thiel Insurance

Lori H.

Friendly, helpful insurance agency. We felt well informed regarding the policies we purchased before we left Highly recommend!

Nicole R.

Hunter was very helpful and able to get my premiums down significantly from my previous insurer while also increasing coverage.

Eric K.

Hunter was super helpful with finding us the insurance solutions that best fit our lifestyle needs. He is thorough and thoughtful and has great follow through.

Hannah M.

As first time homebuyers, we weren’t really sure where to start with homeowners insurance quotes. Hunter was beyond helpful - professional, knowledgeable, kind, and all around a great asset in this journey. He helped us bundle home and auto and found us a competitive quote. For anybody looking for insurance needs, Thiel Insurance is the way to go. I’ll 10/10 be recommending Thiel Insurance!

Christian S.

Hunter and Team have bene great to work with. Knowledgable, responsive, and great service

Joseph J.

Hunter made getting insurance for my stump grinding business, quick and easy. Definitely would recommend.

Kam M.

Help saved us Money. Got back to us really quick with different quote options. Very knowledgeable.

Maynard H.

Hunter, was very helpful and swift with a solution.

Kate-Ben G.

Hunter is authentic, personable and had our best interest in mind. Made the process easy to understand, gave insight where it was due and saved my family money. 10/10 would recommend!

Scott Vanden B.

Responsive, helpful, made it an easy process.

Samuel K.

Hunter at Thiel Insurance has done a phenomenal job with our insurance! We originally started with our home and auto insurance through them and got great rates, we have now switched our Tree business insurance through Hunter as well! Highly recommend Hunter and Thiel Insurance Group!!

Jeffrey M.

We have had great service from Boyd and his group for years. We would recommend them for all your insurance needs.

Kyna S.

Worked with Hunter and Stacey to quickly get an auto and home policy after having an issue come up with our previous home owners policy. Stacey was quick to send me information and forms to get the ball rolling and Hunter was quick to get us a quote and get everything in place!! Both were friendly and the process was so easy! Thank you Stacey and Hunter!

Lori A Van L.

I have had to reach out, after hours, and spoke with Hunter Thiel. HE IS AMAZING! I appreciate being in an unfamiliar situation, calling and receiving much needed info. He quickly and kindly helped me resolve the situation. #thielinsurancelifer

Patrick R.

Stacy was very knowledgeable, helpful, and friendly - I honestly didn't think the process could be that easy! I came away feeling like I was a person, not just a customer 😊😊

Ben R.

Hunter gets things done! I put him on the job a week after three other insurance companies, and he still got me to the signature line first and ended up being the lowest premium.

Ben B.

Started with my boat insurance, and I was so happy with the service and price that I moved all my policy's over. Thanks for always being there when my family has questions!

Jen Guyette H.

I wish I could give 10 stars!! I have to give a HUGE Thank You to Hunter at Thiel Insurance Group, LLC. We insured our camper through them roughly 6 months ago. Out of the blue we get a call from Hunter saying he found better coverage that's more affordable. He added that he did his homework and the company is great to work with. In the 30 years that I've had to pay for insurance, We've never had an agent call me unprovoked with better rates and coverage. Thank you again Hunter. We appreciate you and your attention to detail and for always looking out for your customers! 😃

Joyce B.

Love working with Pat, she has really helped us with a new quote and helped us save mone, but still have great coverag. Thanks Pat

David T.

Responsive! Good Knowledgeable people who remember you.

Greener Grass I.

We began referring our tenants to Hunter out of the Appleton office when he was able to show us that our renters were paying too much for renters insurance through other agencies. He is getting them better coverage (which we like) at a better price (which they like)!

Dean S.

I've been working with Patty at the Appleton office for many years, and her customer service is second to none. She saved my family >$1,000 this year! I highly recommend the Thiel Insurance Team!

Thanks - Dean

JoAnne D.

I just switched over to Badger Plus insurance, through Thiel insurance.

Leah, the agent, was awesome. she was very detailed on informing me what would work best for me. She didn't hesitate on any questions I had.

I'd recommend Leah to everyone.

JoAnne DeBriyn

Sue D.

CHECK THEM OUT-WE GOT WAY MORE COVERAGE AND FOR LESS MONEY via car/rental than the company we have been with since 1980. Great people to work and patient/understanding.

Christy G.

Kim did an AMAZING job! I got an apartment on a Tuesday and was set up with new policies by the time I moved that Friday! From start to finish, Kim had me set up in about a day and a half. Thanks Kim!!!

Emily B.

Great Team and very Efficient!!

Allie W.

My family has gotten insurance through Thiel for generations. I didn't know why, until I received the same kind, respectful, and prompt service. Hunter and Patty have both helped me get the right insurance, for a great value. They're reliable, and always looking for a better value for me.

Jeffrey S.

Always great wo work with. Any time you need to make changes they go over everything to insure you are up to date and covered

Carla K.

Have been with Thiel Insurance Group for over 6 years and always have had excellent service! Just called recently about my currant car insurance with questions and payments and had quick answers and changes for my benefit! I even changed my mind and recalled, and they were so cheerful and helpful! Highly recommend them for your insurance needs!